KAITAN 'ROYAL' KILANG BIJIH BESI DI TELUK RUBIAH

Royal link in iron ore plant

Teoh El Sen | August 22, 2011

Ex-MB Nizar says this has everything to do with the sacrifice of public interest


MANJUNG (Perak): There is a royal link in the controversial project to build an iron ore plant in Teluk Rubiah, Manjung, and one prominent critic alleges that this, coupled with the Perak palace’s cosy relationship with the Barisan Nasional state government, has everything to do with why public interest has been sacrificed to profit a select few.

“BN would always go ahead with something when there’s something in it for them,” said former menteri besar Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin.

“Despite the hue and cry from the community, they don’t give a damn.”

Documents made available to FMT show that the Sultan of Perak owns one of the companies that sold off the piece of land that Brazilian mining giant Vale International is now developing for the multi-billion-ringgit project.

In 2009, KYM Holdings Bhd, through Harta Makmur Sdn Bhd, sold 488 hectares (1,205 acres) of leasehold land in Teluk Rubiah to Vale International and Vale Malaysia Manfuacturing Sdn Bhd for RM196 million.

Vale will use only 450 acres for the plant. The rest of the land, mostly forested, will be a buffer zone.

Checks with the Companies Commission of Malaysia showed that Harta Makmur is 60% owned by Tegas Consolidated Sdn Bhd and 40% owned by RAS Sdn Bhd.

The majority shareholder for RAS is Sultan Azlan Shah. His consort, Tuanku Bainun Mohd Ali, and his son, Raja Ashman Shah, are minority shareholders. Raja Ashman and his siblings are all directors of the company.

Vale’s project has many opponents, including environmental groups and Teluk Rubiah residents and businesses. They fear that it would damage the environment, ruin the local tourism industry and impair the livelihood and health of local residents.

Not a viable option


Nizar said Vale representatives met with him twice in 2008 over proposals for the project.

“I told them that the area should be preserved as a sanctuary. We had virgin jungles, with one of the best species of logs there. I could not afford to lose those.”

He said he proposed another state land in the swampy area of Tanjung Hantu, offering it almost free of charge.

“I was thinking we’re giving you a place with virtually no inhabitants. But before Vale could complete their analysis of the pros and cons of Tanjung Hantu, the government was grabbed, and the deal at Teluk Rubiah went through.”

Nizar headed the Pakatan Rakyat-led government until early 2009, when four defectors helped BN to take over, allowing Dr Zambry Abdul Kadir to replace him.

Nizar alleged that KYM had owed the state government RM20 million in accumulated unpaid charges over the piece of land.

“In order to settle debts to the bank and to the state government, they dumped everything on the Brazilians,” Nizar said. “Somebody’s interest is being taken care of.

“Obviously, Vale was given additional incentives when it decided to choose Teluk Rubiah.

“But I want to put on record that we did not condone using Teluk Rubiah as there were strong objections and it was not a viable option.

“Zambry decided to allow Teluk Rubiah because, one, he gets a good name in the eyes of the palace, and two, KYM gets to settle its debts.”

Nizar questioned whether the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report for the project was tailored to allow the project to go ahead.

“Were there amendments to the EIA? We don’t know, but it could be manipulated.”

Nizar, who is the Pasir Panjang state assemblyman, said he hoped Vale would honour its promise not to pollute the area.

He admitted that it was “a bit too late” to ask for Vale to stop building the factory.

“They’ve already signed all the documents and they will go ahead as they’ve made all the commitments to the Brazilian company.
“There’s nothing much we can do now, however much the environment might suffer.”

Zambry: State has no equity

Perak Consumer Association president Rahman Said Alli said pollution was a major concern.


“We respect royalty, but we are concerned that some people may be misusing the Sultan’s name,” he said. “They should not bandy his name around to obtain certain approvals from government authorities.”

Last January, Zambry said he was aware of objections to the project but added that his government was allowing it to go ahead.

He said the Perak government had no equity participation in the plant itself, but would participate in the port and logistics operations.

Vale, the world’s largest producer of iron ore, started construction on the factory in July. It is expected to start operations by June 2014. The plant will have a dedicated jetty that will be the destination point for Vale ships of 400,000-deadweight tonnes carrying iron ore from Brazil.

Blended iron ore and pellets will be distributed to customers in Malaysia, China, Japan, Australia and other parts of the Asia-Pacific region.

Teluk Rubiah was once a traditional Malay fishing village and was a Malay reserve land.

The exploitation of the village and a portion of the Teluk Muroh forest reserve started in 1983, when the state government proposed that the area be developed for tourism.

The government de-gazetted a 478-hectare portion of Teluk Muroh forest reserve in September 1988, and 247 hectares were alienated to the Perak Development Corporation while 213 hectares remained state land.

A 350-hectare area was turned into the Teluk Rubiah golf course and beach resort.

The original size of Teluk Muroh forest reserve was 917.93 hectares. At one point, it was classified as a virgin jungle reserve.

In July 1989, the government de-gazetted another 163 hectares of Malay reserve land, displacing the villagers. About 10,000 of them had no choice but to move out, but they received some compensation.

In 2001, several environmental groups protested against logging in the de-gazetted parts of Teluk Muroh, pointing out that the area remained under the Sensitive Environment Area classification.

The government responded by re-gazetting a mere 89.83 hectares as forest reserve. However, without any public announcement, it again de-gazetted 121.16 hectares in January 2010.

Also read:

Activists, residents reject iron ore plant

Iron plant good for Perak, says mining giant

AKTIVIS, PENDUDUK BANTAH KILANG BIJIH BESI DI TELUK RUBIAH

Activists, residents reject iron ore plant

Teoh El Sen August 19,2011

Mining giant Vale fails to allay fears of ecological damage and effects on the income and health of locals.

PETALING JAYA: Mining giant Vale International has failed to impress its critics with assurances that its proposed iron ore plant in Manjung will be safe to the environment and will benefit local residents.

A FMT survey found that activists and locals are still overwhelmingly against the project, although it has the eager support of the state government.

In a recent public relations exercise, Vale made a lengthy statement about the mega project’s friendliness to the environment and gave a glowing projection about the economic benefits it would bring to Perak as well as the local community.

However, critics remain unconvinced. Their attitude is summed up by a sceptic’s statement that the plant, which will occupy a 450-acre site at Teluk Rubiah, would help feed only “human greed”.

The locals, most of whom are fishermen, remain worried about the plant’s effect on their livelihood and, worse, their health.

Consumer and environmental groups have consistently voiced opposition against the project. They say that the physical facilities as well as the operations of the plant would destabilise the ecosystem of the area, formerly gazetted as a forest reserve.

Concerns have also been raised that the local tourism industry would take a blow from which it might not recover.

Meor Razak Meor Abdul Rahman (in red), secretary of the Perak Environmental Association, said the state government committed a crime when it “went against all the laws of the land” to convert the affected land from tourism use to industrial use.

He said this went directly against the vision and objectives of the Manjung District Local Plan covering the period from 2002 to 2015. The state government did not hide its eagerness to go ahead with the project, bulldozing its decision against strong objections from residents during a public hearing just four days prior to the re-zoning in February 2010, he added.

“The folk here worked hard to develop a beachside tourism industry and suddenly you change it,” he said. “What’s going to happen to Teluk Batik and the traders there?

“Until today, the state government has not dared to answer us. Why did they do this re-zoning? If there’s no profit, then we don’t need to follow laws? We might as well be lawless.”

The area was gazetted as Environmentally Sensitive Area Class II under the National Physical Plan. This means, according to Meor Razak, it is suitable only for eco-tourism and should have not host any physical development, much less a large factory.

“Class I means you can’t have any development whatsoever, Class II means there should be very little, if any, development, and only Class III means you can you have development.”

Endangering the ecosystem

The re-zoning and the approval of the project went against a slew of government policies, such as the National Environment Policy, National Forest Policy and the National Physical Plan, he said.

Even if the area was gazetted for industrial use, he added, it was not suited for heavy industry.

Vale, when asked regarding these issues, said it was unaware of them, adding that it was in no position to comment on government policies.

The area is rich in varieties of flora and fauna, and Meor Razak said the project would endanger the jungle and its inhabitants.

“The Perak Department of Wildlife and National Parks also assessed that the project area is rich in various fauna and flora, with many protected under the Wildlife Protection Act 1972.”

He said he had found leopards, white belied eagles and the endangered palm plant pheonix paladosa within the area.


“There are protected species of animals in the forest. But their environmental impact assessment (EIA) report conveniently does not talk about the endangered species they would displace.” complained Meor.

Agreeing with Meor Razak, Consumer Association of Penang (CAP) research officer S Mageswari said Vale had not fully addressed the concern that the project would gravely disrupt the entire ecosystem.

She added: “Vale tells us they have their procedures to reduce pollution, but how do you prove it? Have you given us concrete examples of how you’re going to safeguard the environment? At the time being, no.

“It is a concern that what they are doing will disrupt the environment, the fisheries and the birds. For them it is nothing, but we think this is a crime against nature.”

Mageswari noted that the environmental impact assessment (EIA) of the project mentioned that there would be negative impacts if there were no proper mitigation measures.

“Whatever it is they say, whatever mitigation measures they promise, it’s not good enough. We are against the project.

“Why do they need to come here? Why can’t they find another location that is better suited for something like that?

“They claim there would be no problems but these ships that are coming in are very huge vessels. Their movements would definitely affect the fisheries and coral reef.

“We are not convinced and assured. What are they going to do about the dust pollution, the health hazards to nearby residents. The dust, which will have sulphur oxide, nitrogen oxides in it, affects the respiratory system.”

Mageswari is also concerned about the dredging that Vale would need to undertake to build its jetty. She said the company had merely told her a separate environmental impact assessment needed to be conducted.

She said tourism in the area faced instant demise. The popular Teluk Batik beach is just 500m away from the site of the plant. Pangkor is just 5km away.

“Property value will drop drastically. People are already talking about selling their houses to go away.”

Not in the public interest

Another concern, said Mageswari, was that Vale could one day decide to expand its factory and cut down the trees that are now supposed to surround the plant as a “buffer zone”.


Also affected by the project is the Outward Bound School (OBS) in Lumut, the oldest such centre outside the UK. It has now lost the parts of the forest it once used for training.

Furthermore, OBS is not the only institution that has used the jungles in the area for training. The sites are also popular with other educational and training institutions as well as youth organisations and the navy. The government has also used them in National Service field training.

“Now there’s a sign board there that prohibits those from the OBS from going in,” said Perak Consumer Association president Rahman Said Alli. “Every time they go in, they need permission. We feel this project is no longer in the public interest.”

Rahman said several groups, including Friends of the Earth, the Perak Environmental Association and the Perak and Penang consumer associations had demanded that Vale relinquish ownership of the outer parts of the project area, which it was using as buffer zone, to the state government.

“Vale is not doing anything with the jungle land,” he said. “Why not give it back to the government? Do it as your CSR. The Forestry Department would manage it better.

“It’s a win-win situation for all. If Vale can’t even sacrifice a little to do this, we won’t agree to talk anymore.”

Vale said the proposal was being studied but admitted it was not something that could be done easily.

“Vale has an excellent track record in managing the balance between development and environmental responsibility and our credentials certainly make us fit to manage the area,” said a spokesman for the company. “We employ thousands of environmental specialists and managers globally to ensure that sustainability is priority and that commitment is certainly in place for Teluk Rubiah as well.”

VOX POPULI:


Asmah Ali, 58, shop owner

“I’m not sure what are the risks. Surely there’s a lot of dust from the project that would go into my house. I don’t really understand, some people say they called it off. I’m not sure what’s happening.”

A 52-year-old fisherman who requested anonymity

“The people here all know what is happening. There was even a prayer session so that this project wouldn’t happen. If there’s no problem and no danger, we don’t mind. But the problem is that many of our fishermen just shut up after they were paid money.”

Abdan Ismail, 66, businessman

“I’m sure there will be dust and all. If the forest is cut down, then maybe it will be worse. Surely, there is some impact to us because the trees would stop the pollution from coming. But all these things are not up to us to decide. There are a lot of development projects that are stalled because the plans were suddenly changed for the factory. If our lungs are affected, then how?”

Ahmad Zaid, former village chief of Kampung Pasir Panjang

“I was told they met all groups and promised fishermen RM25,000 in cash and RM25,000 in shares. But the members of the Village Security and Development Committee were unaware when I asked.

“Vale said there is no pollution and no effect to the surrounding areas, but I am sure it will affect the fishermen and will pollute the sea.

“Everything Vale is saying is all promises. We don’t believe them. It looks like just a ploy to woo the fishermen. I say: don’t buy that and take the risk.

“If possible, keep the place as it is. Leave it. It has always been a place for tourism. We are not allowed to go in and negotiate for what he want. You know who sold the land, right? It’s hard for us to bring this up. I brought this to the Perak government’s attention, but an officer said, ‘What is this? This isn’t even a national issue.’”

Also read:
Iron plant good for Perak, says mining giant
MONDAY: Royal link in iron ore plant

SEKITAR ALAM VERSI KEMUSNAHAN PANGKOR

Music Video Versi Kemusnahan Hutan Simpan Kekal Pangkor Selatan; Tangkap & Hapuskan Yang Haram Itu! Alunan bahasa alam untuk Si Penguasa yang tidak mahu faham rintihan alam, yang putar alam memusnahkan alam!

Tajuk Asal Lagu: SEKITAR ALAM
Original Video oleh AbdullahJones. (Link: Di SINI)
Lagu & Nyanyian oleh Meor Yusuf Aziddin aka Meor PestaJiwa.
Sajak oleh AbdullahJones
Video Versi Pangkor oleh OM TubeVision Crews.
Gambar dari Lensa OM Crews terjah Pangkor act., Sahabat Alam Malaysia members, FB OM Fans, OM Community dan selainnya dr google, blog dsbgnya.

Coming Soon 'Versi Rubiah'! Join and Help us at Save Teluk Rubiah Page. Tq!



Tiada Kaitan AntaraYg Hidup mahupun Yg Mati.
Khas untuk Yang Haram Jadah!

SIDANG AKHBAR KEMUSNAHAN SERIUS BAKAU PERAK

10.08.2011. Lapangan Tokong Pasir Panjang Laut, Sitiawan.

Sidang Akhbar oleh Presiden Sahabat Alam Malaysia yang diwakili oleh Sdr Meor Razak. Turut serta Wakil Penduduk, Krew OM, Team Lensa Masyarakat, Lajnah Alam Sekitar Pemuda PAS Lumut, Pegawai Pusat Khidmat DUN Pasir Panjang dan beberapa NGO termasuk Persatuan Nelayan Manjung dalam bantahan rasa kekecewaan terhadap Pihak Berwajib terutamanya Kerajaan Negeri Perak yang tidak serius dengan kemusnahan paya bakau terutamanya sekitar daerah Manjung.

Dengan izin Allah, hujan lebat bermula seawal jam 9 pagi memperlihatkan kepada wakil media menyaksikan sendiri kesan-kesan dari lokasi yang dijadikan contoh 'kecil' kemusnahan bakau dan persisiran pantai yang dikonkritkan secara tidak Mesra Alam. Angin kecil pagi itu cukup menyatakan kebimbangan dari wartawan yang hadir dan dapat selami bagaimana penduduk sekitar menghadapi dugaan yang lebih besar tanpa diduga. Ini hanyalah lokasi contoh kecil, bahkan ada yang lebih dasyat sepanjang pantai Negeri Perak. Setelah habis sahaja Sidang Media, hujan berhenti dan para media berkesempatan juga melihat contoh kecil hakisan persisiran pantai dengan lebih dekat dan lapangan yang dahulunya dipenuhi paya bakau ditambak oleh kerakusan manusia yang tidak mempedulikan eko-sistem. Ada yang terkejut besar! dan tertanya siapakah yang meluluskan projek di lokasi contoh ini?!?! Masing-masing tersenyum kerana tahu angkara siapa kalau bukan Si Penguasa yang memerintah Negeri ini.

Terima Kasih kepada Wakil Media dari The Star, BH-Metro-NST, Perak News & Sinar Harian yang turut bersama menyelami permasalahan besar terhadap kemusnahan Bakau, Hakisan pantai serta Pencemaran Alam.


Pembentangan Sahabat Alam Malaysia (SCENE 1/9)


Hujan & Angin KECIL memperlihatkan kesan kepada Para Wartawan (SCENE 2/9)


SIDANG AKHBAR ISU KEMUSNAHAN BAKAU NEGERI PERAK (SCENE 3/9)


SIDANG AKHBAR ISU KEMUSNAHAN BAKAU NEGERI PERAK (SCENE 4/9)


SIDANG AKHBAR ISU KEMUSNAHAN BAKAU NEGERI PERAK (SCENE 5/9)


SIDANG AKHBAR ISU KEMUSNAHAN BAKAU NEGERI PERAK (SCENE 6/9)


SIDANG AKHBAR ISU KEMUSNAHAN BAKAU NEGERI PERAK (SCENE 7/9)


SIDANG AKHBAR ISU KEMUSNAHAN BAKAU NEGERI PERAK (SCENE 8/9)


PERSATUAN NELAYAN MANJUNG TURUT ADU PENCEMARAN LAUT (SCENE 9/9)

Lokasi Sidang Media ini menjadi isu politik dimana UMNO LUMUT aka Pasir Panjang memutarbelit fakta menyatakan sifat rasis mereka menentang pembinaan Tokong ini dan menyatakan angkara Dato Ngeh Koo Ham Adun Sitiawan (DAP) dan disokong oleh DS Nizar Adun Pasir Panjang. Jelas mereka tidak hiraukan permasalahan yang dihadapi Nelayan dan penduduk apabila bakau dilapangan itu dimusnahkan dan pinggiran pantainya dikonkrit yyang tidak menepati hukum alam. Sedangkan jelas semua ini adalah permainan putar belit politik rasis UMNO LUMUT dengan pembongkaran Majlis perasmian atas nama sebuah kawasan pelancongan. Kita tidak menentang pembesaran Tokong, malah menghormati hak mereka, tiada apa salahnya tapi kejumudan rasis itu dimainkan dengan melarikan fakta sebenar. Ini dibuktikan dengan 'Tiket Kupon Makanan' untuk Jemputan Masyarakat Muslim.


Kisah Isu Rasis UMNO LUMUT terhadap Tokong di BLOG MANJUNGMARI
Kisah Keluhan Kemusnahan Bakau di BLOG LEKIYOURROCK9
Laporan Sidang Akhbar di PERAK NEWS

TAYANGAN KOMUNITI FREEDOM FILM DI MANJUNG

29.07.2011, Seri Manjung.

Program Santai Tayangan Komuniti di Manjung (atau ringkasnya TKM 2011) yang memaparkan filem hak asasi manusia dari Pusat Komunikasi Masyarakat (atau ringkasnya KOMAS) berdasarkan hubungkait dengan Hak Asasi Manusia (Human Rights) adalah pertama kalinya dilaksanakan di Manjung.

Tujuannya menyampaikan mesej dan meningkatkan kesedaran masyarakat setempat mengenai isu hak asasi manusia. Selain itu, kita juga berharap agar peserta (penonton) akan berminat dengan penggunaan media popular (seperti video dan komik) untuk menyebarkan mesej mengenai hak asasi manusia.

Maklumbalas yang diterima satu sukses perkiraan sasaran program yang memberi ruang (sesi dialog) kepada peserta berkomunikasi secara terbuka untuk mendidik masyarakat agar berani bersuara, berhujah dan berpandangan sebagai wadah percambahan ilmu berhubung hal-hal yang berkaitan dan menghormati pendapat-pendapat yang berbeza.

Maklumat lanjut Pusat KOMAS di http://komas.org/ dan Freedom Film Festival (FFF) di http://freedomfilmfest.komas.org/.

Fasilitator: Wakil KOMAS -- Sdr Yow Chong Lee
Resource Person: Wakil Peguam -- Sdr Leong (Peguam Yang Terlibat Dalam Krisis Perak)

Local Coordinator (Aktivis Manjung):-
1. Otai Manjung- Blogger Otai Manjung
2. Loh Eng Soon- Aktivis Parti Politk
3. PoG - Blogger Tunduki Hatimu
4. Khairil Azhar - Aktivis Parti Politik
5. Al Hud & Akhi - Blogger Lensa Masyarakat
6. Krishna - Aktivis Parti Politik (AMK Lumut)
7. Kintan & Farid - Contributor Otai Manjung
8. Ika & Maz - Aktivis An-Nisa Seri Manjung
9. CekLi & Isa - Blogger Lekiyourrock9
10. Ustaz Bard - Aktivis Parti Politik


SCENE 1/4 - Video by OM TubeVision.


SCENE 2/4 - Video by OM TubeVision


SCENE 3/4 - Video by OM TubeVision


SCENE 4/4 - Video by OM TubeVision


The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Malay Subtitle)
The International Bill of Human Rights consists of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and its two Optional Protocols. In 1966 the General Assembly adopted the two detailed Covenants, which complete the International Bill of Human Rights; and in 1976, after the Covenants had been ratified by a sufficient number of individual nations, the Bill took on the force of international law.

Video information
Produced by Amy Poncher
Directed by Seth Brau
Produced Jul 06, 2011
Production Company UDHR
Distributor KOMAS

Source: http://www.engagemedia.org/Members/Komas/freedomfilmfest-...
Credit to UDHR & KOMAS (http://www.komas.org/)

SAVE TELUK RUBIAH!
OTAI MANJUNG PAGE
OTAI MANJUNG FANS

BERSIH2.0: LENSA OM BAHAGIAN 1

9 July 2011, Kuala Lumpur. (LENSA OM1)

Setelah diasak beberapa lokasi pergerakan rakyat ke BERSIH 2.0, orang ramai dikepong sekitar Pudu Raya ke Bukit Bintang dari kedua-dua arah. Unit FRU melakukan sekatan dan melepaskan 'gas pemedih mata aka sesak nafas' dan 'air kimia aka minyak panas' memaksa orang ramai berpecah di lorong-lorong jalan tersebut.

Begitupun pada awalnya beberapa pemimpin berbincang dgn pihak PDRM agar memberi ruang kepada kumpulan ini berjalan pulang ke laluan lain dan dipersetujui, namun saat pemimpin memberi arahan agar berjalan pulang dengan aman disekat sekali lagi dari kedua-dua arah oleh pihak PDRM. Malah unit FRU dan PDRM mula bergerak dan melakukan tahanan termasuk pemimpin-pemimpin yang berusaha meminta kerjasama PDRM.


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: SEKATAN PUDU RAYA, UCAPAN DR. HATTA (OM1)


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: SEKATAN PUDU RAYA DARI MAYBANK (OM2)


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: YB NGEH & YB SIVARASA MOHON KERJASAMA POLIS 1 (OM3)


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: YB NGEH & YB SIVARASA MOHON KERJASAMA POLIS 2 (OM4)


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: YB NGEH & YB SIVARASA TEMURAMAH SELEPAS TEMU POLIS (OM5)


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: ARAHAN SETELAH PERSETUJUAN POLIS (OM6)


BERSIH 2.0 RALLY: POLIS MANIPULASI PERSETUJUAN AWAL?! (OM7)

BAHAGIAN 2 KEJADIAN BERMULA DARI PELANCARAN BERSIH 2.0 NEGERI PERAK YANG DISEKAT SEHINGGA HARI KEJADIAN 709:BERSIH 2.0 DALAM PROSES PENGUMPULAN DATA DARI LENSA KREW OM.

CHUA JUI MENG AT DINER & CULTURE NIGHT AMK LUMUT

23.07.2011: Kg. Selamat, Sitiawan, Perak.

Majlis Makan Malam Pemimpin Pakatan Rakyat anjuran Angkatan Muda Keadilan Lumut dengan kerjasama Biro Kebudayaan & Kesenian PKR Lumut.


DATO CHU JUI MENG


YB KULASEGARAN


DATO' NGEH KOO HAM


SDR HAMIDUN, WAKIL DS NIZAR


DR SUMMUGAM

SAVE TELUK RUBIAH!
OTAI MANJUNG PAGE
OTAI MANJUNG FANS

CERAMAH PAKATAN RAKYAT DI BERUAS.

21.07.2011, Beruas. Ceramah DS NIZAR, DATO NGEH, SDR MAZLAN ALIMAN anjuran PAS BERUAS.


Mazlan Azliman


Ngeh Koo Ham


Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin

SAVE TELUK RUBIAH!
OTAI MANJUNG PAGE
OTAI MANJUNG FANS